By Jyoti Jha
When you start experiencing issues within your marriage, the first thought you have is leaving your spouse. But the tricky question is whether you should have a legal separation or a divorce.
We have heard about terms like legal separation and divorce several times. But we often confuse these two terms. In this article, we will provide you with the differences associated with legal separation and divorce.
What Is Separation?
Separation is represented by the time that is away from your marriage. This is when both spouses decide to explore living apart from one another with the attempt of reconciliation of issues or to choose divorce.
Most couples are known to separate in a physical manner, which means they are living in different physical locations. On the other hand, living apart does not always mean that you will be living in two different residences. This is because the couple might reside in the same household for the purpose of financial or custody matters.
In such cases, the couple chooses to live as roommates compared to a married couple.
Separations can be both formal and informal. An informal separation does not involve courts, and couples tend to choose to live apart while proceeding with their divorce. On the other hand, a formal separation, also known as legal separation, is required to be approved by the courts and can affect taxes and marital property.
Moreover, while you are being separated from your partner, you both are considered to be married legally. This means while being in a legal separation, you are not allowed to remarry another individual. So, you must divorce to become eligible to remarry.
Legal Separation Vs Divorce: Differences
In simple terms, the difference between separation and divorce is one’s status of being married. Separation can be stated as being married while not staying in each other’s vicinity. On the other hand, a divorce is a process through which a couple officially ends their marriage.
In most cases, a couple is usually observed to opt for separation for the purpose of reconciliation. Because once you are divorced, reconciliation would be more difficult. Due to this, when you are having a legal separation, you are not walking out of your marital status.
The primary differences between legal separation vs divorce are as follows:
In the United States, legal separation and divorce are two distinct legal processes that couples can pursue when they wish to separate and potentially end their marriage. While the specifics can vary by state and jurisdiction, here are some key differences between legal separation and divorce:
Status of Marriage
Legal Separation: In a legal separation, the couple remains married in the eyes of the law. They live separately and may have court-approved agreements regarding issues such as property division, child custody, and spousal support, but they are not officially divorced.
Divorce: In a divorce, the marriage is legally terminated, and both parties are considered single individuals.
Marital Status
Legal Separation: Because the marriage is still intact, neither party can remarry while legally separated.
Divorce: After a divorce is finalised, both parties are free to remarry if they choose to do so.
Property and Debt Division
Legal Separation: Couples can create agreements regarding property division, spousal support, child custody, and child support. These agreements are legally enforceable.
Divorce: Similar to legal separation, divorce involves property division, alimony, child custody, and child support arrangements. However, divorce proceedings lead to a final court order that legally divides property and establishes support obligations.
Healthcare and Benefits
Legal Separation: Some couples choose legal separation to maintain certain benefits, such as health insurance, that might be lost in a divorce.
Divorce: Divorce usually terminates eligibility for many spousal benefits, including healthcare coverage under one spouse’s plan.
Personal Status
Legal Separation: The couple’s marital status remains unchanged, which might have implications for religious beliefs and social considerations.
Divorce: The marriage is legally dissolved, and the parties are no longer married to each other.
Residency Requirements
Legal Separation: In many states, legal separation does not typically require the same residency period as divorce. It can be pursued even if the couple has not lived separately for a certain period.
Divorce: Many states have residency requirements that must be met before filing for divorce, which can vary from a few months to a year.
Waiting Periods
Legal Separation: Some states do not have mandatory waiting periods for legal separation, but others might have a brief waiting period.
Divorce: Many states have mandatory waiting periods between the filing of divorce papers and the finalisation of the divorce decree.
It’s important to note that legal separation and divorce laws can vary significantly by state, so it’s recommended to consult with an attorney or legal professional who is familiar with the laws in your jurisdiction to understand the specific differences and implications of each option.
What Are The Benefits Of Legal Separation Over Divorce?
Legal separation and divorce are two different legal processes that couples can choose when they are experiencing marital difficulties. While divorce ends the marriage entirely, legal separation allows a couple to live apart while still being legally married. There are several benefits to choosing legal separation over divorce:
- Retaining Marital Status
Some couples have religious, cultural, or personal reasons for wanting to maintain their marital status, even if they are not living together. Legal separation allows them to do this while still addressing the issues that led to the separation.
- Financial Benefits
Legal separation can have financial advantages, such as maintaining certain tax benefits that are available to married couples. It can also allow a spouse to continue receiving benefits like health insurance through the other spouse’s employer.
- Time for Reflection and Reconciliation
Legal separation provides a period of time for couples to reflect on their relationship and decide if divorce is truly the best option. During this time, they might seek therapy or counselling to try to reconcile their differences.
- Social and Family Considerations
Legal separation can be less disruptive to a couple’s social circle and extended family. It can also be an option when there are concerns about how a divorce might impact children, allowing the couple to maintain a more consistent family environment.
- Relief from Joint Liabilities
Legal separation can help protect one spouse from being held responsible for the other’s financial actions during the separation period. It can prevent the accrual of additional joint debts.
- Simplified Divorce Proceedings
If a couple decides to proceed with a divorce after a period of legal separation, the process may be smoother and quicker since some of the issues, like property division and support arrangements, may have already been addressed during the separation period.
- Personal Reasons
Some couples may choose legal separation due to emotional or psychological reasons. They might need time apart to work on personal growth or address individual challenges before making a final decision about divorce.
- Religious Considerations
In some religious traditions, divorce may be frowned upon or not allowed. Legal separation can be a way to adhere to religious principles while still living apart.
It’s important to note that the benefits of legal separation can vary depending on individual circumstances. Each couple’s situation is unique, and what works for one may not work for another. Before making a decision between legal separation and divorce, it’s recommended to consult with legal professionals and consider the emotional, financial, and legal implications of each option.
Final Thoughts
Now you have a better understanding of the differences between a legal separation and a divorce. Legal separation is a better process if you are not absolutely sure about the ways of parting with your spouse.
We advise that you hire an experienced family law lawyer for the purpose of having clarity regarding the step of stepping away from the marriage.
Read More:
What's your reaction?
