By Sofia
Is it illegal to video record someone without their consent? This question goes through the minds of so many people. It is tempting to secretly record video of your harassing boss or when your ex launches a verbal attack against you.
It is worthwhile to have incontrovertible evidence but you also need to look at the cost. It all depends on your physical location during the video recording. It is good to answer the question: is it illegal to video record someone without their consent before you do anything.
Is It Illegal To Video Record Someone Without Their Consent? State And Federal Recording Laws
Can you record in public? It is the common question people ask me every time. The States and the U.S. all have independent laws that govern the legality of surreptitiously recording various communications like telephonic and oral.
Various state laws govern the secret taping of conversations depending on where you are making the recording. You also have to confirm how the federal law protects the element of privacy.
The Federal Wiretap Act
As a response to the outcry of the public regarding the covert recording of the political activist group’s activities by the government, Congress decided to enact the famous Wiretap Act. It came in as part of the Safe Streets Act and Omnibus Crime Control Act of 1968.
Illegal Recording According To The Wiretap Act
The federal Wiretap Act states that it is illegal for an individual to record an electronic, telephonic, and oral communication secretly when the other party of the conversation expects it to be reasonably private.
Exceptions
This law has two main exemptions that can gut it of effect. The video recording will not violet the Wiretap Act when:
- The other party to the communication
- The individual recording secretly is permitted by the law to do so.
Therefore, it is legal to record a conversation if you are part of that conversation hence consents to the video recording. However, this tends to create a very big loophole in real-life situations.
The History Of The Government In Citizen Surveillance Is Not A New Thing
The FBI, in 1956 launched the Counter-Intelligence Program (COINTELPRO) to monitor and infiltrate Martin Luther King Jr., the progressive political activist groups, civil rights groups, the Weather Underground, the Black Panthers and entailed secretly tape recording telephone calls, meetings, and conversations.
The 2013 revelation that the U.S. government was intercepting and analyzing email and telephone conversations of tens and millions of its citizens was received with a lot of shocks. This appalled both the public and media figures. The government enacted new laws after the 9/11 attacks to widen the espionage activities of several government agencies.
Reasonable Privacy Expectation
The Wiretap Act and also every state law that governs secret video recording of conversations only protect the recordings where the people who are being video recorded reasonably expect to remain private.
The context determines whether the individual has a reasonable privacy expectation under certain circumstances. Did the conversation take place in a private or public location? Did the person who was being recorded treat the subject of the conversation as private?
If a person brags at a party on how he cheated on a partner in a business deal, he cannot object to introducing a recording of the admissions as evidence if his friend uses them in a lawsuit. It is crucial to understand this as you look at the whole idea of is it illegal to video record someone without his consent.
Recording Consent
Most state laws that govern secret recording and the federal Wiretap Act allow covert taping in which one or more parties consent. Like earlier noted, you can implicitly make the consent when one of the parties to the conversation records the other.
It also takes place when consumers stay on the helpline after getting the obligatory message that the conversation could be recorded for purposes of quality assurance. The consent can also be explicit when the source of a reporter agrees to speak out on the record for the news story.
Preemption Of The Less Protective State Laws
If any law is less protective than the federal Wiretap Act, it preempts it. Thus, if a law allows secret recording of conversations without the consent of any of the parties it will be void and the federal law will preempt it.
No Preemption Of State The Laws That Are More Protective
The protection that some state laws give to citizens is higher than what you get in the Wiretap Act. In such a case, the federal law does not preempt them and hence their provisions have to be enforced. To get to understand is illegal to record someone without their knowledge; get to know what the state laws say vs. the federal ones.
12 states don’t allow any individual to record a conversation unless all the parties in the communication consent. Therefore, any surreptitious record video is illegal unless you are a law enforcement official and have warrants to make the video recordings.
States that have these laws include Washington, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, Maryland, New Hampshire, Illinois, Nevada, Florida, Montana, Connecticut, Michigan, and California. Be keen on these stipulations if you want to know if it is illegal to video record someone without their consent in the above states.
Penalties
People ask most of the time: is illegal to video record someone without their consent? Yes, it is. In fact, if you violate the federal or state recording laws, you can face jail time, fines, or a court order to pay for the damages in the civil lawsuit.
Criminal Penalties
If you violate the federal Wiretap Act, you can face a possible sentence that may see you go for five-year imprisonment, 500 dollars fine, or even both of them.
If you violate the state law that prohibits secret video recording of communications, the penalty that you get is prescribed by the given state law. All states impose some form of criminal penalties for anyone who violates the secret recording laws.
For instance, if you violate this law in California, you can face possible imprisonment of one year, a misdemeanor conviction, or a fine of $2500.
Civil Penalties
If it is illegal to tape someone without consent in your state, the victim can sue you for the recording. Anyone who wins this type of civil case will get damages.
Things To Keep In Mind Before You Record Someone
Recording someone without their consent is a heinous crime and one shouldn’t do it no matter what. However, if you intend to record someone after obtaining their consent, here are some pointers that you need to keep in mind:
Location Matters
Location plays a vital role in video recording someone without their permission, or sometimes even with their permission. However, the US allows you to video record in public spaces where there’s no privacy exception. But remember, there are also some state-specific laws you must follow before you record anyone. Some of the US states even have laws that restrict audio recording. So, before you record anything, remember to always follow the state-specific laws before you do anything.
Consent is Key
This is the most important factor you need to keep in mind before you even think about video or audio recording someone. If someone has a reasonable expectation of privacy in their home or some other private setting, you cannot record them there. As the right to privacy is important in the US, you shouldn’t record anyone without obtaining their prior consent.
Intent
This is also another important factor that you should keep in mind before you video-record someone. If you’re recording someone to gather crime evidence or making a newsworthy documentary, then the recording you do is lawful. However, if you have malicious reasons to record someone, then it goes without saying- that is illegal.
Reasonable Expectation of Privacy
The overall concept revolves around the ideology of individuals to be free of any unwanted invasion of privacy. There are certain places where privacy must be respected and it is illegal you record someone in that place without obtaining their prior consent. So, always respect the consent of the other party and don’t do anything that hampers anyone’s privacy.
Places and Situations With Reasonable Privacy Expectations
As we discussed about places with privacy exceptions, here we will talk about the places where these restrictions apply. Let’s see which places they are:
Private Residence
People always expect and have higher privacy than in any public place. Therefore, recording someone without their consent in their home is a breach of privacy and is illegal.
Public Restrooms
These are the most private places where you can demand privacy. Hence if you record someone in a public restroom without their prior consent highly invasive and illegal.
Changing Rooms
Similar to public restrooms, changing rooms hold the same weightage when it comes to providing privacy. It is illegal to record someone in a change without obtaining their permission.
Bedroom and Hotel Rooms
Be it a private home or a hotel room, it is illegal to record someone here without their consent. These hold the same weightage as someone’s home and if you record someone there without their prior consent is a serious breach of privacy.
Medical Facilities
Hospitals and doctor’s offices also fall under the places where you can enforce exceptions of the right to privacy. If you record someone without their consent in this setting then it violates the privacy of the individual, gravely.
Conclusion
With this article, you have a clear understanding of: is it illegal to video record someone without their consent. Secret video recordings carry a high level of risk and their consequences vary from one state to another.
A criminal defense lawyer will advise you on the requirements of this law for your state. The attorney will also tell you the possible penalties for violating the law. If you are thinking of secretly recording a conversation, don’t worry.
More Resources:
What's your reaction?
