By The difference between migration vs immigration is perhaps the most widely discussed confusion in global journalism and policy discussion. Although in casual use the terms are used most loosely synonymously, in law, statistics, and scholarly applications, they possess completely separate meanings.
This is what Donna R. Gabaccia states in her journal article, Nations of Immigrants: Do Words Matter?:
“Everybody knows that the United States is a nation of Immigrants.”
An understanding of the particular migration vs immigration definition has the capacity to decipher perplexing global events and advise well on public policy. The following is a detailed examination of the distinction between migration vs immigration.
Here, we will talk about migration vs immigration in legislation and also relating to current international stats.
What Is Migration? Definition, Types & Scope
Migration is the generic overall term. It encompasses the movement of one or more persons, either across a state boundary or within a state. It may be voluntary or involuntary, permanent or temporary.
Definition And Principal Characteristics
Migration is just a movement from one place to another. It’s a very widely used word in geography and demography. It includes every form of human movement. In a comparison of migration vs immigration, we would take migration as the more general and broader term.
- Emigration means leaving a country.
- Displacement means movement under coercion.
- Mobility means the ability to move.
- So, these are some of its related terms.
Types Of Migration
Migration may be classified into several principal categories, attesting to its extent:
1. Internal Migration
Movement from one place within a nation to another. Instances are the global rural-to-urban movement, or a household moving from one state to another, say, Texas to California. Such movements are not categorized by immigration legislation since no crossing of borders occurs.
2. International Migration
The process of one country’s border moving to reside in another. It’s the only meeting point when it comes to discussing migration vs immigration.
3. Circular / Seasonal Migration
Recurrent movement between two or more places, typically depending on the demand for labor (e.g., farm workers) or school terms. The intention is temporary.
4. Forced Migration / Displacement
Asylum seekers and refugees belong in this category. They relocate due to conflict, persecution, or natural disasters. It is a critical distinction under international law between a refugee and a voluntary migrant (UNHCR).
Why People Migrate? Push & Pull Factors?
People migrate for a complex set of reasons, which are typically categorized as “push” and “pull” factors.
When it comes to the push factors, they generally drive people away from their home location. These include the following:
- War.
- Economic status.
- Political instability.
On the other hand, the pull factors attract people to a new location. These include:
- High-paying job.
- High wage.
- Education.
Increasingly, climate change is acting as an effective push factor, driving people to migrate in the midst of devastation and disasters.
The IOM places the number of internal migrants alone at over 760 million globally, over two times that of international migrants.
What Is Immigration? Definition, Legal Pathways & Status
Immigration is a technical and narrowly defined type of migration. It deals with the entry into a host country for the purpose of permanent or long-term residence.
Definition And Distinguishing Features
Narrowly defined, immigration is entry into a foreign nation.
- When people are talking about immigration vs migration, they prefer to use “immigration” because it explicitly implies the legal and administrative aspect of border crossing for settlement.
- The chief distinction is the directional focus: migration is the movement. Immigration is the arrival and settling.
- An “immigrant” is a person who has formally gained legal status to live long-term in a foreign country. This status typically guarantees access to permanent residence or citizenship.
- Immigration comes under the remit of strict immigration law and national sovereignty. Countries manage who comes and settles via various channels:
2. Temporary Visas
These allow entry for a certain finite purpose (e.g., student visas, H-1B work visas in the US).
3. Reunification of Families
It is the method through which immigrants bring close relatives to reside and be with them.
4. Economic/Highly Skilled Immigration
Countries use point systems (e.g., Canada and Australia) or special investor visas to allow highly skilled workers.
5. Asylum/Refugee Status
Forced displacement migrants initially, though, after being given asylum by a host state, become legal immigrants.
- The immigration policy differs significantly from region to region. United States immigration policy, for instance, strongly focuses on employer sponsorship and family ties.
- However, the European Union experience comprises complex patterns of intra-EU mobility (free movement) and external immigration (from outside the EU).
- These immigrants who achieve legal status enjoy substantive rights like the right to labor, social services, and naturalization rights.
- They also have some legal responsibilities, like tax payment and compliance with all local legislation.
- Integration is also one of the key issues of modern migration policy. It mostly constitutes the integration of immigrants into society.
- An effective integration policy reacts to language, culture, and anti-discrimination.
Read Also: What Are The Different Types Of VISAs In the USA?
Migration vs Immigration
The most significant distinctions between Migration vs immigration are as follows.
1. Scope Of Movement
Movement refers to the overall term that covers movement, which is either internal (within a country) or international (across a border).
Immigration is an international movement, and it always implies crossing over into another country.
2. Direction And Perspective
Migration is a movement in itself and does not highlight the perception of any one destination. Immigration is directional, with the focus being on the destination nation (inward movement), with the implied intention being settlement.
3. Intent And Permanence
The movement of migrants can be temporary, seasonal, cyclical, or permanent. Immigration, however, has an implied intention of settlement or residence for a significant duration.
4. Legal Framework
Migration is typically regulated by common national law (in the case of internal migration) or standard international conventions.
Immigration is strictly regulated by specific national immigration statutes, i.e., visas and quotas.
5. Statistical Treatment
Migration analysis takes into account the overall movement flow and people movement between the entire areas. Immigration statistics in reality measure the stock and flow of foreign-born individuals entering a nation in order to settle.
6. Discourse And Narrative
Migration is a more technical and value-neutral term (e.g., “labor migration”). Immigration becomes politicized and attached to heated national debates of identity and security on the borders.
The point being made here is that all immigration is international migration, but most migration overall, especially internal migration, is not immigration.
Global Trends & Data
Taking a glance at recent statistics explains the magnitude of migration vs immigration worldwide.
1. Overall Migration / Immigrant Stock Trends
International migrants have grown steadily in numbers.
An estimated 281 million international migrants worldwide in 2020, according to IOM World Migration Report 2024. It is a large figure but nevertheless a quite small percentage (around 3.6%) of the global population.
The U.S. remains the world’s largest destination country for immigrants in numbers.
But some countries, including the United Arab Emirates and Australia, have more foreign-born residents as a proportion of their total population.
2. Recent Trends (COVID-19, Climate Migration, Conflict)
Recent events globally have transformed migration vs immigration patterns dramatically.
COVID-19
The COVID-19 pandemic set an all-time record low in immigration flows by closing borders and redefining global migration policy.
Conflict-Induced Migration
Crises like the Ukraine conflict produced monster, record-breaking waves of forced migration. They overwhelmed asylum regimes throughout Europe and required temporary protection measures.
Climate Migration
With desertification and sea-level rise speeding up as the planet warms, the number of people involved in climate-induced migration will increase during the 2020s.
Thus, this places new stress on international humanitarian law.
Regional Case Studies
For regions like the EU, the migration vs immigration dilemma is particularly acute because of the Schengen Area.
Free movement allows intra-EU migration with ease, but it becomes difficult to control external immigration and refugees along seacoast borders.
Similarly, in destination countries like the U.S., there is a policy dilemma on how to reconcile its high-demand immigration policy.
This is towards skilled workers with the humanitarian challenge of coping with irregular migration along its border with Mexico.
Legal / Policy Issues & Data Limitations
Immigration vs migration gets blurred when it is tried to be quantified by authorities.
1. Challenges in Quantifying and Defining Migration / Immigration Statistics
Several challenges confront national statistical offices when they try to quantify international migration.
- Definitions of “permanent stay” or “long-term residence” are very different by country, making international comparison difficult.
- A four-year visa student is an immigrant to one country but not to another, skewing international migration figures.
2. Policy Trade-Offs and Tensions
Policy-makers are always caught between two facts.
- Managed immigration is economically beneficial and completes demographic gaps.
- However, the human dimension of large-scale migration demands border control with human rights.
- Restrictive immigration policy for granting access only to high-skilled individuals can also create “brain drain” for source countries.
3. Theoretical / Conceptual Debates
In academia, the theory of migration engages in debates about the causes of migration.
- There are structural theories. For example, disparities in the world.
- And, there are network effects theories. For example, migrants are followed by family and friends.
- Existing research perceives migration as a necessary global phenomenon, contending that bordered countries will only divert, not halt, the migratory pressures.
Expert Tips, Best Practices & Evaluative Criteria
For authors, researchers, and politicians, it is an exercise of accuracy and ethical discourse to mean what one says.
1. Be Specific
Utilize immigration when referring to lawful admission, permanent residence, or the control of the destination nation (e.g., “The U.S. immigration office processed 1 million green cards”).
2. Migration For Scope
Apply migration when defining the overall, general movement, especially when internal movement is involved, flows that are not necessarily permanent, or in speaking of the underlying cause (e.g., “Global migration trends see people move due to climate change”).
3. Check The Law
When defining a particular country’s policy, apply that country’s own terminology. The term “migrant” is inappropriate in some contexts and acceptable in others, so caution is necessary.
4. Story Sensitivity
Immigration is a hot-button political issue. Applying the more encompassing term migration on occasion provides a less polarizing, fact-based basis for debate.
Migration And Immigration: Are They The Same Thing?
So, migration vs immigration are two faces of the same coin.
One who immigrates is immigrating across international borders. However, the fine distinction in the connotation of migration and immigration is in the rights one enjoys.
There are differences in which regulations one belongs to, and in how their mobilization is quantified and challenged internationally. If we all honor the differences, we might reasonably examine the complex demographic change reshaping the world today.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):
Let us get some answers to migration vs immigration FAQs, shall we?
Ans. Emigration is when one leaves a country. It is just the reverse of immigration. If someone emigrates from Country A, then he/she must immigrate to Country B. Both are types of international migration.
Ans. No, legally and technically. An immigrant is a legally admitted foreigner to a nation for permanent residence. Anyone who crosses a border in an irregular manner is more commonly referred to as an irregular migrant, undocumented migrant, or unauthorized immigrant.
They are still considered to be part of international migration movements, but they lack legal immigration status.
Ans. It is easier for international institutions like the IOM and the press to use migrants because migrant is a less specific and politically more acceptable term. “Immigrant” conveys legality and permanence that is different from “asylum seekers”, “temporary workers”, or “displaced people”. Migration is used to circumvent a particular legal ruling.
Ans. Yes. National statistical offices and the census bureau track internal migration around the clock in order to know what happens inside the country demographically.
The information is important for urban planning, distribution of resources, and projecting local economies’ shifts.
Ans. The 1965 Act permanently transformed U.S. immigration policy. It closed the earlier national-origins quota scheme (beneficial to Northern Europeans) and established a new system of family reunification and skill migration.
This transformation reconfigured the demographic composition of the immigrants to the United States.
What's your reaction?
